Lawsuit challenges Montana PSC's approval of NorthWestern Energy-Black Hills Energy merger

Lawsuit challenges Montana PSC's approval of NorthWestern Energy-Black Hills Energy merger
NorthWestern Energy
Add KPAX as a Google Preferred Source

HELENA — A week after the Montana Public Service Commission voted to approve a merger including the state’s largest utility, a lawsuit in state district court is claiming that decision was invalid.

NorthWestern Energy and Black Hills Energy announced Monday morning that their merger is already complete. The New York Stock Exchange has already stopped trading the two original companies and started trading shares of the new Bright Horizon Energy, under the symbol HZN.

However, 350Montana and the Montana Farmers Union – two of the parties that objected to the merger throughout the process – argue courts still have the authority to step in and put a hold on any further integration.

“Under well-settled Montana law, consummation does not moot judicial review or divest this Court of its equitable authority,” wrote Monica Tranel, an attorney representing the two groups. “An entity that acts precipitously to consummate a transaction with knowledge of an imminent judicial challenge does so at its own peril.”

(Watch the video for more on the legal challenge.)

Lawsuit challenges Montana PSC's approval of NorthWestern Energy-Black Hills Energy merger

Commissioners voted 3-2 last Tuesday to approve NorthWestern and Black Hills’ merger, with added conditions related to NorthWestern’s newly acquired share of the Colstrip power plant. The companies are set to continue their utility operations under their current names, but they would be under Bright Horizon as a new holding company.

The plaintiffs argue the PSC didn’t fully consider the potential risks of the transaction, saying the new structure could incentivize the company to redirect investment from Montana toward other states and large data center projects. They said the commission should have reviewed the deal based on whether it would be a net benefit for Montana customers, instead of merely whether it would do no harm.

The plaintiffs also argue the PSC violated Montana’s open meeting laws, when they went into a closed session before making their final decision. It came after Commissioner Randy Pinocci asked a staff attorney if the agency could face “legal consequences” if they approved the merger with the conditions related to Colstrip.

“Do you think this will put us in harm's way of having some lawsuits filed?” Pinocci asked. “What are your thoughts?”

“Your question calls for a legal conclusion, or it requires me to provide the commission with legal advice,” attorney Pamela Snyder-Varns responded. “I can certainly do that in open session right here, but if you would prefer to go into a closed session, that would be a more appropriate forum in which I can answer that question.”

“All right, then I’m going to ask for a closed session, because I think we have to understand the roadblocks that may be in front of us if we support this,” Pinocci said. “So I'd like you to explain in closed session all your concerns, so we can discuss them.”

PSC President Jeff Welborn then agreed to move into closed session.

“Based upon commission counsel's request to move into closed session to discuss confidential strategy and legal advice with the commission, I agree that continuing in open session would harm the commission's litigating position,” he said.

Commissioners left the room and returned after about an hour.

In her filing, Tranel said the justification the commissioners gave was not enough for them to qualify for an exception to open meeting requirements.

“Neither the presence of counsel nor a general concern about legal ‘roadblocks’ alone establishes that public discussion would detrimentally affect the Commission’s position in pending or contemplated litigation,” Tranel wrote.

The plaintiffs argue the PSC’s final order should be void because it was “reached through unlawful procedure.” They asked the judge to put a stay on the order, delay any additional consolidation and prevent the company from making new commercial agreements for power from the newly acquired Colstrip share.

A PSC spokesperson told MTN Tuesday the agency had not yet been formally served in the lawsuit and would have no comment at this time.

NorthWestern and Bright Horizon are not officially parties in the case, but Jo Dee Black, a NorthWestern spokesperson, said they were aware of the filing.

“The merger has closed and we do not anticipate the petition will change the transaction,” Black said in a statement. “The merger creates a stronger, more resilient company with greater resources to meet growing energy needs and provide long-term value to our customers and communities.”

In their announcement of the merger, the companies said customers will see no immediate changes to branding, payment procedures, online accounts or customer service.