NewsMontana News


Billings City Council will again take up non-discrimination ordinance

Council member Penny Ronning made the initiative
Posted at 11:08 AM, Feb 19, 2020
and last updated 2020-02-19 13:08:58-05

BILLINGS — Billings City Council member Penny Ronning reintroduced Monday a non-discrimination ordinance (NDO) to the Council designed to prevent discrimination in employment, housing and public accommodation on the basis of sexual orientation or gender identity.

“I’m not calling it a non-discrimination ordinance. I’m calling it a welcoming diversity ordinance. The city motto is ‘The Magic City: A diverse, welcoming community where people and businesses prosper.’ And that, to me, states that all people and businesses should prosper," Ronning told MTN News on Wednesday.

Ronning said the NDO will be brought to the council on Feb. 24. This meeting is where the council will vote to decide whether to put it on the March 23 agenda.

A previous iteration of the NDO turned into one of the most contentious debates in recent memory at the Billings City Council.

In August 2014, after weeks of debate meetings lasting into the early morning hours, the Billings City Council voted 6-to-5 against an NDO. Then-Mayor Tom Hannel cast the deciding vote, saying the city wasn't ready.

Gay, lesbian and transgendered rights groups backed the measure, noting that similar ordinances in Helena, Missoula and Bozeman had passed with few problems. Certain religious groups, led by the Montana Family Foundation, led the opposition.

"Even though the ordinance definitely has legal language in it that clearly states that discrimination is not acceptable and would be against the city ordinance, it’s really about making Billings a truly welcoming community where all people and businesses can succeed. That’s why I’m calling it a welcoming diversity ordinance,” Ronning said.

The ordinance has the same language as the NDO that former council member Brent Cromley introduced and later withdrew in October 2019.

Ronning said she has supported previous efforts to pass an NDO.

"Brent brought one forward late last year and then he withdrew it. I met with Brent and other council members and the reality is we can never stop. We must always move forward in working for everyone to have equality and for everyone to have their rights protected," Ronning said.

To read the full NDO, click here.

This time, a newly constructed Council will debate the issues. In November, four new members were elected: Kendra Shaw, Pam Purinton, Danny Choriki and Mike Boyett. Incumbent Roy Neese also retained his seat.

Only one member of the current Council was seated during the 2014 vote: Mike Yakawich, who voted no five years ago.

Ronning stressed that her reason for introducing the NDO is to promote economic prosperity in Billings.

"When you take a look throughout the state and see the other cities that have these ordinances in place, their economies are growing. Their populations are growing. When you take a look at the two largest urban centers that do not have one, Billings: our population is fairly stagnant right now, but Great Falls is dropping in population. It really is about the economy of our community and city and looking forward and focusing on what we need to to to make the economy grow," Ronning said.

The population of Billings, Montana's largest city, was 109,550 in July 2018 and had grown about 5% since 2010, according to the U.S.Census. Great Falls' population fell 0.7% during the same time period.

With a public safety mill levy likely on the horizon for Billings voters, Ronning says it's important to provide legal protections for all citizens before the local government asks them to pay more taxes for services like police and firefighters.

"I think it’s important it happens before the public safety mill levy," Ronning said. "We go out and ask for a public safety mill levy and some people are not protected under the law from discrimination and we’re going to ask them to pay more taxes in regard to public safety? Well, they don’t feel safe. We need to make sure that we do have certain legal protections in place for all people.”

Ronning was en route to Washington, D.C., Wednesday to attend the White House's summit on human trafficking.

"The fact that we do not have a federal investigator, not one, (solely devoted to) investigating human trafficking in the state of Montana is absolutely shameful and not acceptable and we need to make our voices really loud. And I plan to do that,” Ronning said.